A man in his fifties pauses with his hand on the door handle outside a modest British church hall at night. White text reads IS AA OUTDATED?; Rethink Drink logo lower-left.

Is AA Outdated? What People Say, and What Research Shows

June 03, 2025•11 min read

By Rethink Drink. For UK adults. Reviewed November 2026.

Is AA outdated?

Not for the people it works for.

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) started in 1935. It's still in most towns in the UK, with around 4,400 group meetings a week across Great Britain, and online too. And the strongest review of the research found that structured programmes based on AA usually helped more people stay completely alcohol-free than other established treatments.

What has changed is everything around it. There are more ways to get help with alcohol now than there were in 1935. So for some people, AA is exactly right. For others, it simply doesn't fit.

That's not a failure of AA. Or of them.

Maybe you're just starting to look into your options.

Or maybe you've done AA... maybe more than once. On calls, people often tell us they've been, sometimes two or three times. Most speak well of it, especially the people. It just didn't fit them.

In short

  • AA isn't outdated for the people it suits. It's free, local, and there tonight, with no waiting list.

  • The research backs it. A 2020 Cochrane review of 27 studies found structured AA-based programmes usually helped more people stay completely abstinent than other established treatments, and did about as well on other measures.

  • AA has changed. Online meetings grew during the pandemic, and in AA Great Britain's latest survey, women were a slight majority of members for the first time.

  • What people question is usually fit: the spiritual language, the labels, and the all-or-nothing goal.

  • There are other routes alongside it: SMART Recovery, NHS alcohol services, talking therapies, medicines, and The Sinclair Method.

  • Check first: if your body depends on alcohol, stopping or cutting down too fast can be dangerous. Speak to your GP (General Practitioner) or local alcohol service before you change anything...

Is AA outdated?

AA is old. That isn't the same as outdated.

It began in Akron, Ohio, in 1935. Its basic text, the "Big Book", came out in 1939. The first AA meeting in Great Britain was held in March 1947, in a room at the Dorchester Hotel in London.

Today, AA Great Britain counts approximately 4,400 group meetings each week. There are no fees. In AA's own words, "The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking."

What AA gives people is real. A room where nobody needs it explained. Free, tonight, local to you. People who've been exactly where you are.

Matt, our co-founder, went to AA. For six months he didn't drink, and went to AA. AA gave him perspective on his own drinking. It gave him peace to know he wasn't the only one struggling.

What do people say about AA?

When people question AA, it's rarely the people in the rooms. It's usually one of four things. Here they are, fairly.

"It's religious."

The Twelve Steps do talk about God. Step 3 reads: "Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him."

But AA says it is "not allied with any sect, denomination, politics, organisation or institution". And AA describes the Twelve Steps as a suggested programme of personal recovery.

For some people, that works beautifully. For others, the language is a barrier they can't get past. Both are fair.

"I don't want to call myself powerless, or an alcoholic."

Step 1 begins: "We admitted we were powerless over alcohol..." For many members, saying that out loud is a relief. It ends years of pretending.

For others, a label sits heavy. We've written about that, honestly, in Once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic?

"It's all or nothing."

AA's goal is not drinking at all. If your goal is to drink less, or to have the choice back, that's a different goal, and AA may not be built for it.

In fairness, AA doesn't ask anyone to swear off for life on day one. Its "24-hour program" is about today: "The current 24 hours is the only period the A.A. can do anything about as far as drinking is concerned." A lot of the pressure comes from our own heads, or from the people around us.

That is not AA, by the way. It's the whole abstinence approach.

"It isn't professional treatment."

It was never meant to be. AA is a fellowship of people helping each other, not a clinic. AA Great Britain says plainly that members aren't qualified to give medical advice, that no member should "play doctor", and that questions about medication belong with your doctor.

Many people use AA alongside medical help, not instead of it.

Does AA still work?

For some people, yes. Very well.

The strongest evidence is a 2020 Cochrane review by John Kelly and colleagues: 27 studies, with 10,565 people. Structured programmes designed to get people engaged with AA improved rates of continuous abstinence at 12 months, and the effect held at two and three years. On other measures, such as how much people drank when they did drink, they did about as well as other treatments.

The review also found these programmes will probably produce substantial healthcare cost savings.

The limits, in fairness: some studies were at high risk of bias, and a summary in American Family Physician notes that none looked at medicines for alcohol alongside AA.

AA helps a lot of people stay stopped. It doesn't suit everyone.

That's not a failure of AA, or of them. It's a fit.

Why doesn't AA work for some people?

Usually, because the goal or the approach doesn't match the person.

Some people don't want to stop completely, or can't yet picture a life without alcohol. Some find the labels or the spiritual side don't fit.

And some do brilliantly for months. Then there's an occasion. One glass... and they're straight back to where they left off.

If that's you, it's easy to decide you just don't have the willpower. But you stopped for months. That takes a LOT of willpower.

Willpower is the wrong weapon in this battle.

Time away from alcohol doesn't always change what a drink means to you. There are reasons for that, and weakness isn't one of them: The alcohol deprivation effect and Alcohol relapse.

For some of us, being told "you can't" just makes us want to more. In Matt's words: "Taking control away never worked for me. It just created more resistance."

That's not AA's fault. It's just worth knowing about yourself.

Is AA attendance declining?

The honest answer is that the numbers aren't directly comparable.

In 2020, AA Great Britain said it had "around 40,000 members" across Great Britain and its Continental European Region, and normally around 5,000 face-to-face meetings a week. Its 2025 membership survey estimated about 32,200 members in the same area.

Those come from different methods, either side of a pandemic that moved many groups online. So they can't tell us much about why numbers have moved.

What the survey does show is who's in the rooms now:

  • Women were 52% of members in Great Britain, a slight majority for the first time.

  • Age: 65% were over 50, though more than three-quarters first came to AA by 50.

  • Long-term sobriety: 42% reported more than 10 years without a drink.

  • Face-to-face meetings are still the most common, with online and hybrid meetings also used.

How has AA changed?

More than people think.

When the pandemic hit in 2020, AA Great Britain reported that most groups moved online, to Zoom, Skype and other platforms. Online and hybrid meetings are still part of AA today.

So if your picture of AA is a church hall in 1985, it's worth knowing that isn't the only version any more.

What are the alternatives to AA in the UK?

You don't have to choose AA or nothing. NICE, which sets health guidance in England, says adults seeking help for alcohol should be given information on, and support to access, community support and self-help groups. It names AA and SMART Recovery.

  • SMART Recovery: a UK charity offering mutual-aid meetings, face to face or online. The NHS says SMART groups help people decide whether they have a problem and build up their motivation to change.

  • Your GP and local alcohol service: the NHS says a GP is a good place to start. They can talk you through assessment and local community services.

  • Medicines: the UK's clinical guidelines say acamprosate and naltrexone are first-line options to help people stay stopped. Nalmefene is licensed to help some people with alcohol dependence cut down. Compared side by side: Acamprosate vs naltrexone.

  • The Sinclair Method: naltrexone taken before drinking, at a time your prescriber sets, with the aim of weakening the desire over time, so you drink less, or stop if you choose to. It's off-label in the UK, and it needs proper support around it. What is The Sinclair Method?

How AA and The Sinclair Method compare, side by side: The Sinclair Method vs AA.

I've left AA. Is it normal to feel guilty?

Very.

If you spent a long time in the rooms, leaving can feel like letting people down. Or like you're tempting fate.

A few things that might help:

  • You can keep what helped. The friendships, the honesty, the routines. None of that has to go in the bin.

  • Leaving a group isn't a verdict on you. It's a decision about what fits now.

  • If you're thinking about drinking again after a long time without, please be careful. Many people find the first drinks after a long break hit harder than they expected. Talk it through with your GP first, and read Alcohol relapse before you decide anything.

Common questions

Do people go to AA and still drink?

Yes, some do. AA's only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking, so you don't have to have stopped already to walk in.

What is the controversy with AA?

Mostly fit, not failure: the spiritual language, the labels, and abstinence as the only goal. The research shows it helps many people stay stopped.

Is AA free?

Yes. AA says there are no dues or fees. Groups cover their costs from members' voluntary contributions.

Can I do AA and The Sinclair Method together?

Some people do, but the two work in different directions: AA's message is not drinking at all, and The Sinclair Method means drinking while it works. More in The Sinclair Method vs AA.

How do I find an AA meeting?

Through AA Great Britain, or its free national helpline on 0800 9177 650.

If you'd like support from us

Rethink Drink is a UK coaching service built around The Sinclair Method. Our programmes include a consultation with an independent prescriber, who decides whether treatment is suitable. Clinical oversight is provided by consultant psychiatrist Professor Jonathan Chick. Any prescription is dispensed by an independent partner pharmacy. Our coaches work with you, week by week, on everything around it.

And whatever happens, you can talk to someone today. Drinkline, the national alcohol helpline, is free and confidential: 0300 123 1110.

Please look after yourself

This page is here to help you understand your options. It isn't medical advice, and it can't replace a conversation with a doctor who can ask qualifying questions.

Before you change how much you drink or start any medication, speak to your GP or a prescriber.

We really hope this post helps. If you have any questions, you can contact us here.

The Rethink Drink team

P.S. If you're reading this for someone you love, we created a page for you: how to support someone struggling with alcohol.

Sources

  1. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain. Historical data. https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/About-AA/Historical-Data

  2. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain. AA structure in Great Britain. https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/About-AA/AA-Structure-in-Great-Britain

  3. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain. Who we are. https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/get-help-now/who-we-are/

  4. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain. The 12 Steps of AA. https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/about-aa/the-12-steps-of-aa

  5. Alcoholics Anonymous World Services. What is "the 24-hour program"? https://aa.org/faq/what-24-hour-program

  6. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain. Safeguarding in AA: medical advice (wallet card). https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Safeguarding_in_AA__Medical_Advice_Wallet_Card.pdf

  7. Kelly JF, Humphreys K, Ferri M. Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programs for alcohol use disorder. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2020, Issue 3. Art. No.: CD012880. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD012880.pub2. https://www.cochrane.org/evidence/CD012880_alcoholics-anonymous-aa-and-other-12-step-programs-alcohol-use-disorder

  8. Salisbury-Afshar E, Kauppila G. Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programs for alcohol use disorder (Cochrane for Clinicians). American Family Physician, 2021; 103(5): 272 to 273. https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2021/0301/p272.html

  9. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain. Alcoholics Anonymous goes online during Covid-19 pandemic (6 April 2020). https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/Media/News-&-Articles/Alcoholics-Anonymous-goes-online-during-Covid~19-pandemic

  10. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain. Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain publishes membership survey (27 July 2026). https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/2026/07/27/alcoholics-anonymous-great-britain-publishes-membership-survey/

  11. NICE. Alcohol-use disorders: diagnosis and management (QS11), quality statement 2: community support networks and self-help groups. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/QS11/chapter/quality-statement-2-community-support-networks-and-self-help-groups

  12. UK SMART Recovery. About. https://smartrecovery.org.uk/about

  13. NHS. Alcohol support. https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/alcohol-advice/alcohol-support/

  14. Department of Health and Social Care. UK clinical guidelines for alcohol treatment, chapter 10: pharmacological interventions. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/clinical-guidelines-for-alcohol-treatment/10-pharmacological-interventions

Rethink Drink

Rethink Drink

Rethink Drink is a UK coaching service for people who want to change their relationship with alcohol using The Sinclair Method. Our articles explain the method, naltrexone and drinking less in plain English, written by our coaches and checked against the evidence. Rethink Drink is run by Matt Brindley and Bruce Rose.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog

The Sunday Reset

Every Sunday, we share a 2-minute insight into the logic of the Sinclair Method.

Join thousands of others for our weekly newsletter and change how you see the problem,

because when you change the way you look at things, the things you look at change.

… There’s a reason we’re called Rethink Drink!

Rethink Drink Footer Logo

Copyright Rethink Drink Ltd 2023-2026 | Company Registration Number 14619896

The Sinclair Method | Privacy Policy | FAQ | Login | Free UK Alcohol Units Calculator | What is the Sinclair Method?