
Acamprosate vs Naltrexone: Which Is Better for Alcohol, and Can You Take Both?
Neither is simply better: acamprosate helps you stay stopped, naltrexone can help you stay stopped or, used The Sinclair Method way, drink less over time, and whether to take both is your prescriber's call.
In short
Same licensed goal. In the UK, both are licensed to help people who have stopped drinking to stay stopped, alongside support.
But naltrexone has two uses. The usual UK way is daily, after you've stopped. The Sinclair way is only on days you plan to drink, before drinking, to drink less over time. That second use is "off-label", which means a doctor prescribes a licensed medicine in a way its UK licence doesn't cover. It's legal, and common across medicine, but the prescriber takes on extra responsibility for that decision [16]. Acamprosate isn't used that way.
Different ways of working. Acamprosate is thought to calm the brain's over-excited state after long-term drinking. Naltrexone blocks the brain's opioid receptors, which are part of alcohol's reward.
Different strengths. In the big reviews, acamprosate did a little better at keeping people completely alcohol-free. Naltrexone did a little better at stopping a slip becoming heavy drinking. When the two were compared directly, there was no clear winner.
Different bodies suit different medicines. Acamprosate isn't suitable with kidney problems. Naltrexone isn't suitable with serious liver problems, or alongside opioids, including some common painkillers.
Can you take both? It has been studied. In the biggest trial, adding acamprosate to naltrexone didn't help more than naltrexone alone. It's a prescriber's call.
Check first: if your body depends on alcohol, stopping or cutting down too fast can be dangerous. Speak to your GP (General Practitioner) or local alcohol service before you change anything. Our free units calculator and AUDIT-C check give you a starting picture in a couple of minutes. They can't tell you whether your body depends on alcohol; a doctor can.
Acamprosate and naltrexone are the two first-choice medicines in the UK for helping people stay off alcohol once they've stopped.
But naltrexone can be used in two very different ways.
The usual UK way is the one set out in NICE guidelines. That's why it's how most GPs and NHS services prescribe it: every day, once you've stopped drinking, to help you stay stopped.
On The Sinclair Method, it's taken only on days you plan to drink, before drinking, to help you drink less over time. More on the difference: Should naltrexone be taken daily or before drinking?
Acamprosate has one job: helping you stay stopped.
So here are all three side by side: acamprosate, naltrexone the usual UK way, and naltrexone the Sinclair way.
Neither medicine is simply "better". In the big reviews, acamprosate did a little better at keeping people completely alcohol-free, and daily naltrexone did a little better at stopping a slip turning into heavy drinking [9][10].
All of these are prescription-only medicines. A doctor or other qualified prescriber helps you choose, based on your health and your goals.
You might be weighing them up for the first time.
Or you might have been here before.
On calls, people often tell us they've already tried a lot... AA, rehab, a detox, acamprosate, naltrexone bought online and taken on its own. And the story we hear most is some version of "I was sober for months. Then one drink, and I was straight back where I started."
I know that one well. I was prescribed acamprosate myself. More on that below.
Below: what each is, how each works, what the evidence says, who shouldn't take them, and whether you can take both... With every source linked as we go, and listed at the bottom.
Whether one is right for you is a decision for a prescriber who knows your health.
Acamprosate vs naltrexone at a glance
Acamprosate | Naltrexone (usual UK use) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Goal | Stay alcohol-free | Stay stopped, and stop a slip becoming a relapse | Drink less over time, or stop if you choose |
UK licence | To help people who are dependent on alcohol stay alcohol-free, with counselling | To help prevent relapse and reduce craving, as part of a full treatment programme | Not licensed for this use. Prescribed off-label (see above) |
Usually started | Once you've stopped; UK guidelines say it can be started before or during a medically assisted detox | Once you've stopped, or during or after a detox | While you're still drinking. If your body depends on alcohol, a doctor checks that first |
How it's thought to work | Helps rebalance the brain's "accelerator" and "brake" chemicals after long-term drinking | Blocks opioid receptors, reducing part of the reward from alcohol | The same block, but timed with drinking, so each drink brings less reward and the learned relationship with alcohol weakens over time |
What the research says it's better at | Staying completely alcohol-free [7] | Stopping a slip turning into heavy drinking [8] | Cutting heavy drinking. Fewer trials, mostly small, and results vary (what the research shows) |
Who usually prescribes | GP, specialist alcohol service or hospital | GP, specialist alcohol service or hospital | Usually a private prescriber. Many GPs won't (My GP said no) |
How the body clears it | It isn't broken down by the liver. It leaves the body unchanged, through the kidneys [1] | Broken down mainly by the liver, then cleared through the kidneys [3] | The same as daily naltrexone |
Main reasons it may not suit you | Kidney problems; breastfeeding | Serious liver problems; taking or needing opioids | The same as daily naltrexone |
How you take it | Daily, as prescribed | Daily, as prescribed | Only on days you plan to drink, before drinking, at a time your prescriber sets |
A table can't tell you what's right for you. It's a starting point for a conversation with a doctor.
One word of warning before we go further...
Naltrexone has two completely different uses, so the table shows both. There's far more research on the usual daily way than on the Sinclair way, and we'll keep the two apart all the way down. The difference is explained in full here: Should naltrexone be taken daily or before drinking?
What is acamprosate?
Acamprosate is a prescription medicine for alcohol dependence. You might also see it under the brand name Campral. It's often described as an anti-craving medicine, one that helps reduce the desire to drink [17].
Its UK licence is to help people who are dependent on alcohol keep away from alcohol once they've stopped, and the product information says it should be combined with counselling.
It's taken daily, as prescribed.
It's the most prescribed of the alcohol medicines by GPs in England, by a LONG way. In the 12 months to July 2026, GP practices issued about 171,000 prescriptions for acamprosate, against about 20,000 for naltrexone (and that naltrexone figure includes prescriptions for opioid problems too), according to OpenPrescribing.
How does acamprosate work?
Your brain runs on a balance of chemical signals. Some speed things up (glutamate, the accelerator). Some slow things down (GABA, the brake).
Years of heavy drinking push that balance out of shape... and when you stop, the system can be left over-excited.
Acamprosate is thought to help settle that balance back down. The UK product information says it may work by supporting the brain's calming signals and dampening glutamate.
That "may" matters. Nobody fully knows how it works.
What matters more to most people is what it doesn't do. It isn't a deterrent, so it won't make you ill if you drink. And the product information is clear that it doesn't protect you from the harm of continued heavy drinking. It's built for staying stopped.
What is naltrexone, and how does it work?
Naltrexone is an opioid antagonist (an opioid blocker).
When you drink, alcohol triggers the release of endorphins, your body's own feel-good chemicals. They land on opioid receptors in the brain... And that provides a reward.
Naltrexone sits on those receptors and blocks them, so the endorphins have almost nowhere to land, which is how the reward cycle is interrupted.
The usual UK way
In its usual UK use, it's taken daily, as prescribed, once you've stopped drinking. Its UK licence is to reduce the risk of relapse, support abstinence and reduce craving, as part of a full treatment programme (Adepend product information).
The Sinclair way
The Sinclair Method uses the same medicine differently: only on days you plan to drink, before drinking, at a time your prescriber sets. More on that below, and here: Should naltrexone be taken daily or before drinking?
We've written a full explainer here: Naltrexone for alcohol in the UK.
Which is better, acamprosate or naltrexone?
It depends what you're trying to do. And the differences are smaller than most comparison pages suggest.
Here's what the biggest reviews found.
Acamprosate and staying completely alcohol-free. A Cochrane review pooled 24 trials, with nearly 7,000 people who had already stopped drinking. Acamprosate lowered the risk of going back to any drinking (to 86% of the risk on a dummy pill), and added around 11 more alcohol-free days on average. Its effect on heavy drinking wasn't clear.
Naltrexone and heavy drinking. A separate Cochrane review pooled 50 trials, with 7,793 people. Naltrexone lowered the risk of going back to heavy drinking (to 83% of the risk on a dummy pill). Its effect on whether people drank at all was less clear.
The UK clinical guidelines put it in plain terms too: naltrexone can reduce the risk that a lapse turns into a full relapse.
When researchers put the two side by side:
A 2013 review in the journal Addiction found acamprosate had the larger effect on staying alcohol-free, and naltrexone the larger effect on heavy drinking and craving. The authors were careful, though. Most of the comparison was indirect, few acamprosate trials reported heavy drinking, and some of the gaps could be chance.
A 2014 review in JAMA looked at 123 studies. Trials that compared the two directly found no significant difference between them.
A 2023 update in JAMA (118 trials) backed both as first-choice medicines, alongside psychological support. Roughly, for every 11 people treated with acamprosate, one more avoided returning to drinking than would have on a dummy pill. For daily naltrexone, it was about one in 18 for any drinking, and one in 11 for heavy drinking.
Read that again... Both help. Neither works for everyone. And both were tested alongside support.
In UK guidelines, the choice between them comes down to things like your goal, your kidney and liver health, whether you take opioids, and what you'd prefer.
And if your goal is to drink less?
First, it's a recognised goal. In the UK, NICE guidelines say drinking less can be the right goal for some people [5], and the World Health Organization counts reducing drinking, not only stopping, as a goal of treatment [18].
The reviews above are almost all about staying stopped. Far fewer trials have tested naltrexone the Sinclair way, in people who are still drinking.
One of the best known is from Finland. 121 people with alcohol dependence started without a detox and kept drinking. Those who had naltrexone alongside coping-skills therapy did best: over 32 weeks, 27% never went back to heavy drinking, against 3% on a dummy pill with the same therapy. With general supportive therapy, naltrexone made no difference. After 12 weeks of daily tablets, people took it only when they felt a craving [14]. Dr Sinclair was one of the authors.
That's one trial. The full picture, including its limits, is here: what the research really shows.
What happened when I took acamprosate?
It happened to me... over, and over. My longest time without a drink was six months, and I thought I'd cracked it.
I was in secondary care (a specialist NHS alcohol service) with The Recovery Partnership, going to their meetings... They prescribed acamprosate, and I went to AA alongside it.
"I wasn't drinking. But I wasn't free from it either... I couldn't stop thinking about it. And I was miserable."
I took the tablets. I didn't drink. But alcohol had never been more involved in my life.
The prescription was for six months... Six months and two weeks later, I was drinking again. Heavier than ever.
Plenty of people use acamprosate, with support, to stop and stay stopped.
For me, the problem wasn't one medicine or another... It was the whole abstinence approach.
Those six months put time between me and my last drink. They didn't change what a drink meant to me... My brain remembered EXACTLY what alcohol felt like.
That's my experience, certainly not a promise or a verdict for yours. I've told the whole story here: Once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic: really?
If "sober for months, then one drink" sounds familiar, you're not alone. And it isn't a willpower problem. It's covered here: Understanding alcohol relapse.
Who shouldn't take acamprosate or naltrexone?
Your prescriber checks this. But it helps to know what they're looking for.
Acamprosate may not be suitable if you:
Have kidney problems. It's cleared by the kidneys, so your kidney function is checked first.
Are breastfeeding.
Are pregnant or planning a pregnancy. UK guidance says alcohol medicines should be avoided in pregnancy unless the benefit outweighs the risk.
Are a child or an older adult. The Campral leaflet says it isn't recommended for either.
Naltrexone may not be suitable if you:
Have serious liver problems, including hepatitis or liver failure. It's broken down mainly by the liver, so your liver is checked first [3].
Have severe kidney problems.
Take, use or are likely to need opioids. That includes some prescription painkillers like codeine and tramadol, methadone, and some cough medicines. Taking naltrexone while dependent on opioids can cause dangerous withdrawal.
Are pregnant or breastfeeding.
One more thing worth knowing about naltrexone. After you stop taking it, you can be more sensitive to opioids than before. Your prescriber will talk you through that.
Because acamprosate isn't broken down by the liver, UK guidelines [4] say it's probably the safer of the two for people with advanced alcohol-related liver disease. And because naltrexone blocks opioids, acamprosate is the one that doesn't get in the way of opioid painkillers. That's often what decides it.
That's all down to your prescribing doctor to discuss with you.
More on naltrexone and other medicines: Does naltrexone interact with other medications?
What are the side effects?
In brief, from the UK product information.
Acamprosate: the most common is diarrhoea. Others listed as common include stomach pain, nausea or being sick, wind, itching, a rash, and changes in sex drive. In the Cochrane review, diarrhoea was the only side effect reported more often than on a dummy pill.
Naltrexone: the most commonly listed include nausea, stomach pain, headache, trouble sleeping, feeling anxious or restless, joint and muscle aches, and feeling tired or weak.
Most side effects are mild. If anything worries you, speak to your prescriber or pharmacist. Don't stop or change a medicine without talking to them.
More detail: Naltrexone side effects in plain English.
Can you take acamprosate and naltrexone together?
On calls, people sometimes ask us this.
It has been studied. The biggest trial is COMBINE, run across 11 US sites, with 1,383 people who had recently stopped drinking, over 16 weeks.
What it found:
Naltrexone, with regular check-ins from a healthcare professional, helped people have more alcohol-free days and delayed a return to heavy drinking.
Acamprosate showed no benefit over a dummy pill in that trial, with or without extra therapy.
No combination did better than naltrexone alone.
That's one trial, though. Other trials, pooled in the Cochrane review above, did find a benefit for acamprosate, and researchers still debate why COMBINE didn't.
The UK product information records that naltrexone raises the level of acamprosate in the blood, and neither medicine's leaflet lists the other as one to avoid.
So it isn't ruled out. But there's no strong evidence that two is better than one... and whether to combine them is your prescriber's decision, not something to try on your own.
How is The Sinclair Method different?
Everything above is about staying stopped.
The Sinclair Method has a different goal altogether. So it's worth being clear:
Two completely different ways of using naltrexone, with
Two completely different relationships with drinking, for
Two completely different goals.
Neither way is "wrong". Daily naltrexone is a legitimate medical approach, and it helps some people who want to stop. The Sinclair Method uses the same medicine differently, to work on the reward while you're still drinking.
In its usual NHS use, naltrexone is taken daily, after you've stopped, to help you stay stopped.
The Sinclair Method uses naltrexone while you're still drinking: only on days you plan to drink, before drinking, at a time your prescriber sets.
With the reward blocked, every drink is a shift with no pay... So over time, the aim is that the brain questions the relationship, the desire weakens, and you drink less. Or stop, if you choose to. The science behind it is explained here: What is pharmacological extinction?
It isn't an overnight fix. It's a learning process, and for many people a longer-term journey.
It's not the medication itself that makes the method, it's the protocol of how to take it.
Why the timing matters: Why take naltrexone before drinking?
That use is off-label in the UK and outside UK guidelines. Off-label means a doctor prescribes a licensed medicine in a way its UK licence doesn't cover. It's legal, and common across medicine, but the prescriber takes on extra responsibility for that decision [16]. Doctors can prescribe off-label, but they take responsibility for it, which is one reason many GPs won't: Can I get naltrexone from my GP?
Acamprosate isn't part of The Sinclair Method. It's built for staying stopped, and it isn't designed to work while you're drinking.
So if you're comparing the two because you want to drink less rather than stop, that changes the conversation with your doctor. Say so. Nalmefene is the medicine licensed in the UK to help some people cut down, and NICE says cutting down can be the right goal for some people: Alcohol treatment options in the UK.
The Sinclair Method is explained in full here: What is The Sinclair Method? You may have seen Dr Sinclair's 78% figure. It comes from his own clinics in Finland, not a controlled trial; controlled trials show a smaller, real effect, and results vary. The evidence, in full: what the research really shows.
Neither medicine is meant to work alone. NICE recommends both acamprosate and naltrexone alongside psychological support.
Taking a tablet cannot change our habits. Over time, the medicine can quieten the desire... But the routines you've built around a drink over years? That's the real work.
Support matters on The Sinclair Method too: Why support matters on The Sinclair Method.
If you'd like support from us
Rethink Drink is a UK coaching service built around The Sinclair Method. Our programmes include a consultation with an independent prescriber, who decides whether treatment is suitable. Clinical oversight is provided by consultant psychiatrist Professor Jonathan Chick. Any prescription is dispensed by an independent partner pharmacy. Our coaches work with you, week by week, on everything around it.
And whatever happens, you can talk to someone today. Drinkline, the national alcohol helpline, is free and confidential: 0300 123 1110.
Common questions
Is acamprosate the same as Campral?
Yes. Campral is a brand name for acamprosate, the active ingredient. Your pharmacist may give you a different brand or a generic version, and it's the same medicine either way. If you're unsure which one you've been given, ask your pharmacist to check.
Can I drink on acamprosate?
Acamprosate won't make you ill if you drink. But it's licensed to help you stay alcohol-free, and the product information says it doesn't protect you from the harm of continued drinking. If you're drinking while on it, tell your prescriber. UK guidelines say they should review whether it's helping.
Do I have to stop drinking before starting either one?
For their licensed use, yes, usually, because both are prescribed to help you stay stopped. UK guidelines say acamprosate can be started before or during a medically supervised detox. If your body depends on alcohol, a doctor needs to look at that first: Do I need a detox first?
Can my GP prescribe acamprosate or naltrexone?
Yes. Both can be prescribed by a GP, a specialist alcohol service or a hospital. In many areas a specialist service starts them, and your GP may take over later. Naltrexone the Sinclair way is different, and many GPs won't prescribe it: My GP said no.
Which is better for cravings?
Neither clearly wins. Both are described as helping with cravings. In the 2013 review, naltrexone's effect on craving was a little larger, but the difference wasn't clear-cut. Your prescriber can help you choose, based on your health, your liver and kidneys, and what you're aiming for.
Can I switch from one to the other?
Yes, people do, if one isn't suiting them. It's a decision for your prescriber, who'll look at why, and at your liver, kidneys and other medicines. Don't stop or swap on your own. Tell them what you've noticed, so they can make the right call.
Before you change anything
Before you change how much you drink or start any medication, speak to your GP or a prescriber.
This isn't medical advice, and it can't replace a conversation with your doctor.
I really hope this post helps. If you have any questions, you can contact me here.
Matt
Read next
Alcohol Deprivation Effect: Why One Drink Turns Into Many
It explains why my six months on acamprosate ended "heavier than ever".
Sources
MHRA Products. Acamprosate gastro-resistant tablets: Summary of Product Characteristics, listed under acamprosate calcium. products.mhra.gov.uk
MHRA Products. Campral EC gastro-resistant tablets (acamprosate calcium): patient information leaflet. products.mhra.gov.uk
MHRA Products. Adepend film-coated tablets (naltrexone hydrochloride): Summary of Product Characteristics, listed with the other UK naltrexone products. products.mhra.gov.uk
Department of Health and Social Care. UK clinical guidelines for alcohol treatment, chapter 10: pharmacological interventions. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/clinical-guidelines-for-alcohol-treatment/10-pharmacological-interventions
NICE. Alcohol-use disorders: diagnosis, assessment and management of harmful drinking (high-risk drinking) and alcohol dependence (CG115). https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg115
NHS. Alcohol use disorder: treatment. https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/alcohol-use-disorder/
Rösner S and colleagues. Acamprosate for alcohol dependence. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2010 (CD004332). https://www.cochrane.org/evidence/CD004332_acamprosate-alcohol-dependent-patients
Rösner S and colleagues. Opioid antagonists for alcohol dependence. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2010 (CD001867). https://www.cochrane.org/CD001867/ADDICTN_opioid-antagonists-alcohol-dependence
Maisel NC, Blodgett JC, Wilbourne PL, Humphreys K, Finney JW. Meta-analysis of naltrexone and acamprosate for treating alcohol use disorders: when are these medications most helpful? Addiction, 2013; 108(2): 275 to 293. Summary: https://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/26544/
Jonas DE and colleagues. Pharmacotherapy for adults with alcohol use disorders in outpatient settings: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA, 2014; 311(18): 1889 to 1900. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/1869208
McPheeters M and colleagues. Pharmacotherapy for alcohol use disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA, 2023; 330(17): 1653 to 1665. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37934220/
Anton RF and colleagues. Combined pharmacotherapies and behavioral interventions for alcohol dependence. The COMBINE Study: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA, 2006; 295(17): 2003 to 2017. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/202789
Bennett Institute, University of Oxford. OpenPrescribing (NHS England prescribing data, August 2025 to July 2026). https://openprescribing.net/
Heinälä P, Alho H, Kiianmaa K, Lönnqvist J, Kuoppasalmi K, Sinclair JD. Targeted use of naltrexone without prior detoxification in the treatment of alcohol dependence. Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology, 2001; 21(3): 287 to 292. https://www.cpsp.pitt.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/3-VIIH3-2001-Targeted-Use-of-Naltrexone.pdf
OpenPrescribing.net (Bennett Institute, University of Oxford). Alcohol dependence medicines (section 4.10.1), including acamprosate calcium: NHS England prescribing data. https://openprescribing.net/bnf/041001/
MHRA. Off-label or unlicensed use of medicines: prescribers' responsibilities. https://www.gov.uk/drug-safety-update/off-label-or-unlicensed-use-of-medicines-prescribers-responsibilities
Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust. Acamprosate: patient information leaflet. https://www.royalfree.nhs.uk/patients-and-visitors/patient-information-leaflets/acamprosate
WHO and UNODC. SDG indicator 3.5.1 metadata: coverage of treatment interventions for substance use disorders. https://mdgs.un.org/sdgs/metadata/files/Metadata-03-05-01.docx

